We all know liars exists, wolves do run around and many, though no doubt sincere, can be self-deceived. Some christians can be quick to take every word at face value and easily fooled whilst others, albeit often out of sincere motive, lead people to believe in unbiblical theology and gospels full of half-truths that can leave genuine people further away from Jesus than they realise.
Because of these things, whenever questions of professions of faith and personal belief in Jesus come up, it raises inevitable questions. How do we know if this person is genuine or not? How do we know that their profession is genuine? Inevitably, when these questions get raised, someone will pipe up, ‘it’s not for us to judge. It is only for Jesus to judge.’ Sage as this may sound, is it true and more importantly, is it biblical?
What is true is that no Christian individual or church is tasked with finally deciding who does and doesn’t belong to the kingdom. Contrary to popular belief and joke-lore, The Apostle Peter is not standing at the gates of Heaven determining who can and cannot come in. God and God alone decides who belongs to the kingdom and who does not. Indeed, God chose who he would save at the beginning of time and then sent Jesus to effect his saving plan. He not only determines who will belong in the end by judging their hearts, he actively chose who would belong in the very beginning and determined to save and include them.
No Christian individual or church has any right to overrule God’s choice. This means there will inevitably be people in Heaven we are surprised to see there and, no doubt, some people we might be shocked to see missing. Only God sees hearts perfectly and only he decides who ultimately belongs and who doesn’t. We cannot make any judgement that overrules the Lord’s. No human being (other than Jesus) has any part in determining who gets to glory and who doesn’t.
With that said, does that mean we musn’t judge who belongs? Of course not! The bible is full of instructions to us to judge whether people really belong or not. We are given steps to church discipline that involve us making judgements about professions of faith that end with us literally treating (and, therefore, judging) a person as an unbeliever. When the keys of the kingdom are given to the church, Jesus tells his church that whatever they bind on earth will be bound in Heaven; that is, they are given the authority to judge the credibility of professions of faith. The bible has a number of places where we are told to evaluate people by their fruit and to test the spirits. These are meaningless instructions if Jesus expressly does not want his people to make any judgement whatsoever about the spiritual standing of his people.
We are frequently given ‘tests’ of genuine faith in the bible that we are expected to apply to someone. These tests were often applied by the Apostles as they comment on the genuineness of people’s faith; both individuals and churches. Without wishing to patronise you, it should be evident the Apostles are not God (or gods), have no right or ability to overrule Jesus and cannot see hearts any more perfectly than the rest of us. This didn’t stop them making these judgements.
Taken altogether, it seems Jesus does want us to make judgements about the genuineness of professions. He wants us to avoid self-deception and to ask whether we are personally truly saved. He wants us to avoid importing wolves into the church and encourages us to protect the church from them. He wants us to judge professions such that those in ongoing sin are not welcomed as though they belong when they show they do not (cf. 1 Cor 5; Jam 2). He wants us to avoid mixing light with darkness and seeking fellowship between Christ and Belial (cf. 2 Cor 6) and to therefore not welcome unbelievers into membership of the church. All of these things require the church to make judgements about the genuiness of a person’s profession.
Again, it bears saying that the church will not do this perfectly. We are not infallible. But we are given specific ways to judge professions (which is odd if we are not to ever make such judgements) and particular instructions on how to treat those whose lives undermine their profession (which is impossible if we are never to make such judgements).
The church is, of course, expected to make judgements about whether people are walking rightly with Jesus or not, whether they actually belong to the kingdom or not, and therefore whether to include them in the church or not. Our lack of perfection in doing so, our inability to do it without mistake, is no reason not to do it at all. We are specifically expected to make these judgements, having been given instructions by Jesus to do so. It may sound wise and humble to insist that we cannot judge hearts, but it is ultimately arrogant to refuse to do what Jesus asks us to do.
What Jesus asks doesn’t require us to peer perfectly into a heart before we can make a judgement; he asks us to judge outward behaviour using biblical criteria he has given. Might we get it wrong? Of course! But if Jesus asks us to do, albeit fallibly, we are arrogant to ignore him. Given he asks us to do it, refusing to judge a profession out of kindness strikes me as more arrogant still; we certainly aren’t kinder than Jesus!
Judging professions of faith is not only biblical, it is absolutely necessary. It is necessary to protect the church from those who would destroy it. It is necessary for the sake of our witness to the world so people can know who are genuine and who is not. It is necessary to protect the gospel from those who would claim to believe it but do not.

I agree. I think what I would emphasize is that this is best done in the context of the local church. It’s why I originally had questions about Russell Brand. It was not that I wanted to speculate on my blog or social media. I dont think that’s my job and it would distract from what I did want to say. Nor is it that the right person with sight place in the hiersrchy has to do it. It’s because 1. It was away from the local church and body discernmen. 2. It means we see people now distancing themselves as attending when they were much more involved. I fully open responsibility for who we have baptised at our church
Yes, I agree the primary place for this is the local church and they are best placed to make an assessment rather than Christians from afar.
I don’t think that precludes us making judgements as believers elsewhere, but we just have to be conscious (if and when we do) about our limited view of matters when we only see some public things. Nevertheless, if a public Christian figure is doing things unrepentantly that are clearly and undeniably not in keeping with genuine faith, I don’t think we are duty bound to claim ignorance and throw the matter back to the local church. Some cases are clear.
I agree again. I’ve got something I can;t remember if I’ve published yet but I ask similar questions and my point is that I can’t read hearts but I can observe much to the same level as the local church would providing there isn’t missing information. That’s the one qualification and the other as I said that really it is the local church because that’s where the difference happens. When Russell Brand was first platformed as a Christian Dave Williams and Steve Kneale’s assessment didn’t really change anything. When I engage publicly in debate with some people, then I might think that my assessemtn of their words and behaviour affects whether I go into it as a conversation brother to brother or not. Even then I suspecti f I start to assess the person I might distract from the point I want to make. But yes we can make assessments to a degree. I’ve listened to much of what Russell Brand and Tommy Robionson have said. I’ve not heard anything approaching a credible profession o faith that I’d be happy to baptise so I disagree with those who say the batism wasn’t a problem. However, maybe Brand said somethin to Bear Grylls in private or Charlie Kirk asked him to cut the waffle once the cameras were off. I don’t know – though you can guess where my assumption lies. With behaviour. I think that the iss ue is this. I think when a bloke in his 50s settles down with his wife and kids that this isn’t definite evidence of anything more that they’ve settled down. I think though it is reasonable to ask how a person responds under pressure. Even allowing for the possibility that he genuinely thought he was innocent, there could have been other ways to approach the case that would have reflected fruit of repentance. Again the unknown is maybe he did have those arguments with his legal team The final question then is how he responds to the sentence because Scripture tells us how to whether or not we believe a decision and punishment are just
Agree. Only God sees the heart and only He really knows who are His (2 Tim 2:19). We can only make any decision based on outward appearances, especially behaviour over time. Perhaps better to say discern rather than judge? As you correctly point out, only Jesus is the Judge and He will judge absolutely righteously. Every blessing. Steve