I saw this clip from Romesh Ranganathan’s podcast. It is an episode with Hannah Fry, who is Professor for the Public Understanding of Mathematics at Cambridge. Ranganathan himself is a former secondary school Maths teacher. I think the point he makes, with which Fry agrees (and, incidentally, I agree with it too), is worth thinking about a bit more deeply.
Ranganathan argues that teaching some pupils certain aspects of Maths was a waste of everyone’s time. He suggests that they don’t have a passion for the subject and they’re probably not going to do a job that depends on knowing all of this. His view was that many of these kids could have been enthused and the opportunity was wasted because the curriculum insisted on teaching certain things that weren’t going to be relevant to them.
In essence, I agree with him. My slight point of departure is that I don’t think this is confined to lower level sets. I think there is plenty of Maths taught that, for many in higher level sets, it is also irrelevant. I was alright at Maths and in higher level sets at school. But I didn’t go on and use almost any of that Maths in my later A-levels, degrees or work. There is some Maths I use in my everyday life that is useful and probably could have been focused on more at GCSE level (understanding interest rates, percentages and their impact on your mortgage, for example), but the vast majority of it I forgot straight after the exams and never used ever again. I don’t think I have used a protractor, compass or set square since and most of the Maths I need to live my life and do my job is minimal. I am probably one of those (despite being higher set Maths material at GCSE) for whom ‘it is not for me’ rings true. If we had just focused on more relevant stuff, more of us might at least have found it useful going forward.
My purpose here is not to go on about the merits of how Maths is taught in school. The same issues ring true across the board. My English Literature A-level succeeded in effectively ruining classic literature and the reading of novels for me. Until I was able to refine it down to the specific things I really wanted to study, my History & Politics degree (certainly the first year) bore all the hallmarks of what Ranganathan described. As a former teacher (RE, History & Politics if you’re bothered), the same issues existed there too, where it felt like we were forced to teach a lot of pupils things that were not especially relevant to them and, in the process, probably ruined any love for the subject we might have instilled.
As much as these things are at issue across the school curriculum – and this is the point I am reeling around to – we also seem to replicate it in many of our theological colleges too! So much of what we teach people feels as though it lacks any great relevance to them or for their ministry. Our teaching very quickly becomes academic, which tends to just be a discussion of a thing for its own sake, to show we have the reading, writing and analytical skills to dissect it. But immediate relevance to our ministry, there is often very little and the number of times any of our people actually ask us anything about it, we can count on the fingers of one hand. Suffice to say, my top notch 20,000 word dissertation on theological influence of evangelicals on the politics of Northern Ireland has come up close to zero times during the course of my ministry (I know it’s impossible to imagine!) You could argue that was my own fault for choosing it, which would be a fair enough criticism, but even the taught stuff often had limited application to any actual day to day ministry.
The problem with this is that it is easy to send the message that theology is not for everybody; that there are a set of people for whom it is ultimately irrelevant. We can do that in our churches just as well as we can do it in seminary. But both church and seminary are usually full of people committed to the necessity of theology and have taken an active interest in it. If we are still failing to make it relevant under those circumstances, and failing to show people its actual implications for everyday life, there is surely something deficient about how we are doing it altogether.
Perhaps worst of all, just as Romesh Ranganathan said, we have this opportunity to instil a lifelong enthusiasm for theology and for pastoral ministry that we often miss, and even kill off altogether, because we insist on teaching stuff that is neither wholly relevant nor especially thrilling. We then wonder why we end up with dull, academic, uninspiring pastors who don’t preach very well applied or especially relevant sermons. My only defence of them is that they are doing what we have taught them to do and told them repeatedly is good preaching and teaching. If many people grow to hate Maths and are turned off it because of how it is taught, and that is often replicated across the national curriculum, we probably ought to sit up and take notice when it comes to the teaching of theology too.

Yeah I’m not convinced and this comes with a long term level of frustration about the maths stuff. Most people are using more maths or dependent on more in life than they realize but a lot is subconcious. This may actually be more so for those setted lower. Thextesl issue is often thst those teaching don’t spot the everyday connection and struggle to teach concepts etc in.sn accessible way. Additionally knowing about does not mean we all need to know in the same way. An operations planner does not need to be able to derive every formula to forecast or calculate capacity but they need to know the formula and where it comes from. There would I argue be fewer traffic jams if people from planners to drivers knew some things we assume are irrelevant. I think here is the greater link. Too often theology is communicated badly by those who enjoy it for themselves but have not really clicked on why it matters